Youth Scrutiny Panel provides vital feedback

A new Youth Scrutiny Panel, which provides stop and search scrutiny, has received National recognition for providing vital feedback to the Derbyshire Constabulary.

The panel was formed as part of ongoing work with Derby Youth Justice Service, to give young people the chance to review bodycam of stop and searches and provide an important voice from our community on policing processes.

The panel has only been running for just under a year but has already shown to provide young people’s views and lived experiences within the community.

During the panel meetings, police powers and processes are reviewed, alongside bodycam video of officers conducting stop and searches. Afterwards, scrutiny on the video is provided and discussions are had on ways these stops could be improved.

The feedback given is then sent directly back to the officers involved in the stop and search, alongside being fed back to internal training teams for review.

From the feedback provided, processes and training have been revised internally, and a gap in youth education discovered. It was highlighted that the stop search inputs given at schools are given too late in age, therefore, new inputs have now been designed for primary aged children and included within the Mini Police scheme.

Alongside this, the youth scrutiny board has gained National recognition within the Youth Justice Board, as good practice and strong partnership working.

Superintendent Webster said, “All the young people involved have been respectful, professional, and honest throughout the sessions.

“Their feedback given has really helped to provide an insight into how we police young people, which has given us the opportunity to look at ways to improve.

“All the officers involved have been blown away by the responses from the young people and have been able to reflect and improve their own stop and search practices.

“To thank the young people, we held a recognition event, giving achievement awards to those involved to highlight their commitment and professionalism in making policing better for their peers.

“We will continue to hold the Youth Scrutiny Panels and look forward to the further learning that we can build on to continue to provide the best service to the public.”

Jaz Sanghera, Service Manager for Derby Youth Justice Service said, “The Stop and Search Scrutiny Panels have been a significant collaboration and approach for Derby Youth Justice Service (YJS).

“We truly respect the dedication shown by Derbyshire Constabulary namely Superintendent Webster and Acting Inspector Potts.

“Panels offer immense value, as they provided our children and young people with an important platform to have their voices heard and make a meaningful impact.

“Panels have encouraged transparency and have educated the children and young people about their rights, responsibilities, and the workings of the justice system; building knowledge and understanding that can benefit them throughout their lives. Those involved can see that their feedback has led to changes, changing their trust and perceptions.

“We and the young people involved have especially respected the promotion of diversity and inclusion encouraging inclusive dialogue that enhances the discussions and ensures that all voices are heard, fostering a culture of equality.

“In summary, these panels provide a crucial mechanism for children and young people to influence practices that affect them, ensuring that the justice system is more transparent, inclusive, and responsive to their needs.

“I look forward to 2025 where these panels continue to bring about positive changes in community safety and cohesion.”